Sunday, February 25, 2018

Motifs and Motives

Lauren Journet
Professor Shirk
Global Politics of Terrorism
25 February 2018
Motifs and Motives
            During the early 1700s, the Golden Age of Piracy roared in popularity as pirates took over ships and claimed fortune and followers. Towards the end of the 1700s, the Reign of Terror took the lives of the noble and civilian alike. The early 1900s and the Holocaust brought methods of eugenics and ethnic cleansing to an entire country. Beginning with the Golden Age of Piracy and the Reign of Terror and then shifting towards the Holocaust, there appears to be a theme with the attacks that occurred across the globe. Not only are these three periods of time examples of extraneous violence, but these incidents of terror also stem from both political and economic motives.
The pirates came to power during the Golden Age of Piracy from the years of 1716 to 1726. At this time, there was an expansion in trade and commerce across the Atlantic Ocean, giving pirates access to valuable goods on ships. At first glance, pirates seem like merely troubled criminals. But the political effects of the time were paramount. The pirates were well acquainted with their surrounding political circumstances. However, their knowledge of the absolute monarchy did not mean that they respected its power. In fact, the pirates directly rejected the monarchy. Being against trade meant being against the empire. Even some of the more developed countries such as Britain, France, Portugal, and Spain were not powerful enough to protect themselves from the pirates (“Golden Age of Piracy”). They lacked the fleets and men necessary to successfully regulate the pirates- another testament to the political atmosphere of the Golden Age of Piracy. The more obvious motivations were still present, and economics did play a large role in piracy. The pirates collected immense riches while simultaneously wreaking havoc on the system of trade. The pirates were stealing money and goods not only to make a statement but also out of pure enjoyment. Most pirates associated their time on the ship with a vacation from the normal life of poverty.
The Reign of Terror took place in France and lasted from September of 1793 to July of 1794. During this time, there were about 16,594 death sentences in the country. While savage, these sentences were did not come without warning. The political infrastructure in France was crumbling, with the traditional absolute monarchy faltering. The leader at the time, King Louis XVI, called the Etats-General into session for assistance and was shocked when the assembly refused to disband until a new constitution was created. The functions of the monarchy were then suspended, and the king and queen were held prisoner before both being executed (“Marie Antoinette and the French Revolution”). In The French Revolution and Early European Revolutionary Terrorism, Mike Rapport explains, “Private citizens also had a part to play, not least in offering denunciations and information on ‘suspects’” (Rapport 68). Anyone who was suspected to support the nobility was executed along with the king and the queen. This made up a great portion of the 16,594 death sentences. There were also outstanding economic difficulties in France. The country was deep in their debts due to a series of wars fought and financed alike, such as the Seven Years War. In addition, the noble paid little to no taxes but spent excessive amounts of money living their lavish lifestyles.
            The Holocaust itself lasted from roughly 1939 to 1941, but years of oppression and destruction preceded and followed this timeline. Many people know this to be an era of time in which mass genocides and killings were rampid, but there was much more that contributed to the madness. The Treaty of Versailles, effective in 1920, initiated the Guilt Clause, which labeled Germany as an aggressor of World War One. This clause restricted the German army to 100,000 troops and resulted in reparations for the country. The Nazi Party then ran on an anti-government nationalist platform. After this, when Hitler came to power, he used politics to spread the ideas of eugenics and the oppression of Jewish people. The Law for the Prevention of Genetically Diseased Offspring (1933) constructed a mass sterilization program. The Blood Protection Law (1935) criminalized marital and sexual relations with Jewish persons (“The Holocaust and World War II: Timeline”). Hitler implemented these laws and used his political power to isolate the entire groups of people, the Jewish population included. But this maltreatment also stemmed from a deficient economic system. Germany’s state of depression worsened following the Treaty of Versailles. The country was crippled by debt and high unemployment after World War One.
            The Golden Age of Piracy, the Reign of Terror, and the Holocaust all claimed countless lives. On the surface, these attacks appear as isolated incidents of violence. Spanning across nearly two hundred years, each of the incidents shares a common trait. A closer examination of the three attacks brings a theme of political and economic motives to light. This understanding of the three incidents serves as an explanation for the use of violence amongst three very different dominating powers- the pirates, the French, and Hitler.


Works Cited
“Golden Age of Piracy.” Notorious Privateers, Buccaneers, Pirates and
Their Exploits, www.goldenageofpiracy.org/.
“The Holocaust and World War II: Timeline.” United States Holocaust Memorial Museum,
United States Holocaust Memorial Museum,
www.ushmm.org/wlc/en/article.php?ModuleId=10007653.
“Marie Antoinette and the French Revolution.” PBS, Public Broadcasting Service,
Rapport, Mike. “The French Revolution and Early European Revolutionary Terrorism.” The

Routledge History of Terrorism, Routledge Publishing, 2015.

4 comments:

  1. Just a heads up, I am having a lot of issues with formatting. Maybe Tuesday before class I can take a couple of minutes to show you what is going on from my end but the only way I could make this post visible was if I highlighted the background white and made the font a dark shade of red. If there are any issues I would be happy to email you a copy. In the meantime, I'm sorry for the inconvenience.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Lauren,

    I may have a fix for you. Control a, go up to text color, go over to highlight, and select "none". Then copy and paste it back into here. This should do the trick.

    I like how you clearly lay out the three cases you wish to use in the exploration of the topic. Maybe it would have been better to stick with just two of your favorite cases. Really focus on extracting as much detail out of the reading as you can to support your argument. If I am understand your argument correctly, you suggest that its not just the surface-level acts of violence in the middle of the event that we should focus on, but we should also look at greater societal trends, such as economics as well? Perhaps as more of a micro-behavioral level? Am I understanding this correctly?

    -Dan

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think that your essay is laid out well, hitting the three time periods you stated in your introduction. I feel like your idea of deciding political/economic motive gets lost during some of the description of each time period. After some of your explanations of what time period we are looking at, I think a brief sentence that pulls us back to your thesis and stating if your going to be talking about economic/political motives for this time period would be helpful.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hey Lauren,
    Another formatting tip: I have been using Pages to write my posts and then I upload them to Blogger, but before doing so I reformat by using the font, text size, and style buttons at the top of the draft post page. I have been changing everything to the "normal" setting, and this seems to have worked for me!

    On another note, I really enjoyed reading your blog post! We have been making connections between each case of potential terrorism in class, but I thought your attempt to draw more connections across the events helped reexamine each instance and form detailed links between seemingly unrelated events. However, at times I did feel that you included some summary that may have been more effective it were transformed into a distinct analysis of political and economic motives. Going off of Zoe's point, an easy fix for this would be to include a sentence or two linking your points within the paragraph back to the thesis.

    ReplyDelete